Buttercooky Bakery Menu
Located in Floral Park, NY, Buttercooky Bakery is a haven for those with a sweet tooth. Known for their custom cakes, pastries, and desserts, this bakery offers a wide range of delectable treats. From winter holiday delights like the Dubai Chocolate Croissant Pistachio to mouth-watering pies like the Mini Key Lime Pie, there is something for everyone. Customers rave about the friendly staff and the irresistible Tres Leches Cake. Whether you're craving a classic pastry or a unique custom cake, Buttercooky Bakery is sure to satisfy your sweet cravings. With options for delivery and takeout, this bakery makes it easy to indulge in their delicious offerings. Don't miss the chance to experience the heavenly treats and cozy atmosphere at Buttercooky Bakery.
Winter / Holiday Treats
Pies
Breakfast Pastries
Croissants
Bread/Bagels
Brownies & Donuts
Rings/Horns
Showcase Cakes
Mousse Cakes
Individual Slices
Cheesecakes
Cupcakes
Cake Pops
French Pastries, Tarts, Eclairs
Large Cookies & Sweets
Cookies by the Pound
Coffee / Espresso/ Tea / Hot Coco
Candles
Custom Order (Cake, Bread, Cupcakes, Cookies, ETC...)
Winter / Holiday Treats
The Dubai Chocolate Croissant
$10.75
Dubai Chocolate Donut
$6.45
Sprinkle Cake
$32.50
Snowflake Cupcake Vanilla
$4.75
Snowflake Cupcake Chocolate
$4.75
Frozen Cupcake Chocolate
$4.75
Frozen Cupcake Vanilla
$4.75
Snowman Cupcake Chocolate
$4.75
Snowman Cupcake Vanilla
$4.75
Pofiteroles French Pastry
$12.25
Pumpkin Pie Cruffin
$9.00
Dark Chocolate Cherry, Cranberry, & Pistachio Bark 1/2 LB
$31.20
Dark Chocolate Almond Bark
$31.20
Milk Chocolate Hazelnut Bark 1/2 LB
$31.20
Bag of Fans 1/2 LB
$25.65
Chocolate Madeline Cookies
$13.75
Lemon Drops 3/4 LB
$13.75
Chocolate Madeleine Cookies
$13.75
Pefeffernusse 1 Lb
$24.95
Sugar Free Cookies 1LB
$36.20
1LB Bag of Pistachio Biscotti
$33.45
Madeleine Cookies
$13.75
1LB Bag of Cranberry Biscotti
$33.45
1LB Bag of Hazelnut Biscotti
$33.45
Blue Mitten Cookie
$5.65
Pink Mitten Cookie
$5.65
Purple Mitten Cookie
$5.65
Yellow Hot Cocoa Cookie
$5.65
Blue Hot Cocoa Cookie
$5.65
Beige Hot Cocoa Cookie
$5.65
8" Apple Lattice Pie
$28.75
8" Pecan Pie
$36.10
8" Blueberry Lattice Pie
$28.75
8" Cherry Lattice
$28.75
Mini Key Lime Pie
$8.75
Mini Pecan Pie
$10.00
Mini Apple Crumb Pie
$10.00
Mini Blueberry Lattice Pie
$10.00
Mini Cherry Lattice Pie
$10.00
Mini Apple Lattice Pie
$10.00
Raspberry Torte
$37.45
Pies
Breakfast Pastries
Pumpkin Loaf Slice
$6.85
Cheese Danish
$6.55
Almond Cheese Danish
$6.60
Pecan Danish
$6.60
Apricot Danish
$6.60
Prune Danish
$6.60
Small Apple Turnover
$4.45
Large Apple Turnover
$7.20
Peach Boat
$6.85
Apple Boat
$6.85
Apple Crumb Muffim
$5.65
Blueberry Muffin
$5.65
Corn Muffin
$5.65
Bran Muffin
$5.65
Banana Nut Muffin
$5.65
Chocolate Chip Muffin
$5.65
Crumb Cake Slice
$4.05
Elephant Ear
$7.80
Chocolate Cigar
$5.95
Raspberry Cigar
$5.95
Raspberry Hamantaschen
$5.95
Apricot Hamantaschen
$5.95
Prune Hamantaschen
$5.95
Russian Tea Cake
$6.25
Sfogliatella
$6.85
Railroad Bar
$7.45
Biscoff Croissant
$9.00
Plain Croissant
$6.20
The CROOKIE Croissant
$9.00
Pain Au Raisins
$9.00
Oreo Croissant
$9.00
Golden Oreo Croissant
$9.00
Chocolate Croissant
$9.00
Pecan Croissant
$9.00
Tres Leches Croissant
$9.00
Banana Pudding Croissant
$9.00
Pistachio Croissant
$9.00
Dulce De Leche Croissant
$9.00
Strawberry Icing Croissant
$9.00
Almond Croissant
$9.00
Jelly Cronut Croissant
$9.00
PEARfect Almond Bliss Croissant
$9.00
Frutti Di Bosco Croissant
$9.00
Cannoli Croissant
$9.00
Carrot Croissant
$9.00
Nutella Toasted Hazelnut Croissant
$9.00
Apple Croissant
$9.00
Apricot Croissant
$9.00
Creme Brulee Croissant
$9.00
Strawberry Almond Glazed Croissant
$9.00
Pain Au Suisse Croissant
$9.00
Croissants
Bread/Bagels
Add Butter to Bagel or Roll
$1.75
Add Cream Cheese to Bagel or Roll
$1.75
Plain Bagel
$2.20
Sesame Bagel
$2.20
Everything Bagel
$2.20
Plain Roll
$1.25
Egg Roll
$1.25
Poppy Roll
$1.25
Sesame Roll
$1.25
Rye Bread
$7.85
Ciabatta Bread
$5.95
French Baguette
$3.75
Italian Bread
$3.75
Semolina Bread
$3.75
Fudge Brownie
$5.95
Pecan Brownie
$7.20
Oreo Brownie
$7.20
Glazed Vanilla Donut
$3.15
Jelly Donut
$5.60
Chocolate French Cruller
$3.15
Vanilla French Cruller
$3.15
Brownies & Donuts
Rings/Horns
Powdered Almond Horn Horn
$7.20
Chocolate Dipped Almond Horn
$7.20
Large Hard Icing Apple Horn
$19.00
Large Crystalized Sugar Apple Horn
$19.00
Large Apple Crumb Horn
$19.00
Large Cheese Ring
$19.00
Large Chocolate Horn
$19.00
Large Pecan Ring
$19.00
Large Fruit Ring
$19.00
Large Crumb Cake Sqaure
$17.80
Chocolate Flower Celebration Cake
$35.00
Vanilla Flower Celebration Cake
$35.00
Vanilla and Chocolate Flower Cake
$35.00
Strawberry Shortcake
$36.00
Carrot Cake
$36.85
Fresh Fruit Salad Cake
$41.00
Cannoli Cake
$46.85
Small 7 Layer Cake
$16.50
Large 7-Layer Cake
$32.25
Black Forest Cake
$35.00
Mocha Cake
$35.00
Chocolate Shadow Cake
$32.50
Vanilla Shadow Cake
$32.50
4" Chocolate Mini Birthday Cake
$17.45
4" Vanilla Mini Birthday Cake
$17.45
Large Fruit Torte
$47.50
Dulce de Leche Cake
$35.00
Banana Pudding Cake
$36.50
Biscoff Cake
$41.15
Black Chocolate Truffle Cake
$44.95
Funfetti Cake
$35.00
Oreo Buttercream Cake
$34.95
Golden Oreo Buttercream Cake
$34.95
Checkerboard Log Cake
$34.95
Showcase Cakes
Mousse Cakes
Chocolate Mousse Cake
$46.45
Chocolate Tiramisu
$46.45
Traditional Tiramisu
$46.45
French Strawberry Shortcake
$46.45
French Chocolate Strawberry Shortcake
$46.45
Hazelnut Chocolate Mousse
$46.45
Pistachio & Black Forest Mousse
$46.45
Red Velvet Mousse
$46.45
Oreo Mousse
$46.45
Silk & Satin Mousse
$46.45
Passion Fruit Mousse
$46.45
Vanilla Chocolate Mousse
$46.45
Raspberry & Chocolate Mousse
$46.45
Small Tres Leche
$12.35
Tres Leche
$47.75
Pumpkin Mousse Cake
$46.45
Tiramisu Slice
$8.25
7-Layer Cake Slice
$7.45
Carrot Cake Slice
$7.45
Napoleon Slice
$7.45
Individual Slices
Cheesecakes
7" Italian Cheesecake
$37.45
7" NY Cheesecake (Gluten Free)
$28.15
7" Chocolate Fudge Cheesecake
$31.00
7" Oreo Cheesecake
$32.00
7" Pumpkin Cheesecake
$33.45
7" Red Velvet Cheesecake
$29.95
7" Strawberry Cheesecake (Gluten Free)
$33.45
10" NY Cheesecake
$50.25
10" Chocolate Fudge Cheesecake
$55.30
10" Strawberry Cheesecake
$67.80
Individual Strawberry Cheesecake (Gluten Free)
$8.10
Individual NY Cheesecake (Gluten Free)
$6.25
Individual Oreo Cheesecake
$8.15
Raspberry Cheesecake French Pastry
$8.45
Vanilla Classic Cupcake
$3.15
Chocolate Classic Cupcake
$3.15
Carrot Cake Cupcake
$3.75
Fudge Brownie Cupcake
$4.40
Red Velvet Cupcake
$3.75
Minnie Mouse Cupcake Vanilla
$4.40
Minnie Mouse Cupcake Chocolate
$4.40
Mickey Mouse Cupcake Vanilla
$4.40
Mickey Mouse Cupcake Chocolate
$4.40
Spiderman Cupcake Vanilla
$4.40
Spiderman Cupcake Chocolate
$4.40
Oreo Cupcake Vanilla
$3.75
Oreo Cupcake Chocolate
$3.75
Cookie Monster Cupcake Vanilla
$4.40
Cookie Monster Cupcake Chocolate
$4.40
Elmo Cupcake Vanilla
$4.40
Elmo Cupcake Chocolate
$4.40
Football Cupcake Vanilla
$4.40
Football Cupcake Chocolate
$4.40
Rainbow Cookie Cupcake Vanilla
$4.40
Strawberry Cupcake
$4.40
Cupcakes
Cake Pops
Chocolate Cake Pop
$3.70
Oreo Cake Pop
$3.70
Red Velvet Cake Pop
$3.70
Vanilla Cake Pop
$3.70
Funfetti Cake Pop
$3.70
Seasonal/Holiday Cake Pop
$4.15
Lobster Tail
$8.95
Traditional Cannoli
$5.65
Chocolate Cannoli
$6.20
Cheesecake Brownie French Pastry
$8.45
Oreo Mousse French Pastry
$8.45
Biscoff French Pastry
$8.45
Black & White French Pastry
$8.45
Mont-Blanc French Pastry
$8.45
Red Velvet French Pastry
$8.45
Black Forest French Pastry
$8.45
Piece of Cake French Pastry (Gluten Free)
$8.45
Strawberry Mousse French Pastry
$8.45
Opera French Pastry
$8.45
Silk & Satin French Pastry
$8.45
Salted Caramel Brownie French Pastry
$8.45
Chocolate Tiramisu French Pastry
$8.45
Lemon Strawberry Shortcake French Pastry
$8.45
Pistachio Sunflower French Pastry
$8.45
Hazelnut Chocolate Mousse French Pastry
$8.45
MatchaMisu (Matcha & Tiramisu)
$8.45
Charlotte Royale French Pastry
$8.45
S'MORES Cream Puff
$8.45
Banana Milk Chocolate Bar
$8.45
Creme Brulee
$9.00
Vanilla Bean French Tartlet
$9.75
Blueberry Tartlet
$9.75
Tropical Tart Coconut Passion Fruit Tartlet
$9.75
Apple Crumble Tart
$9.75
Lemon Meringue Torte
$9.75
Custard Eclair
$8.95
Tres Leches Eclair
$8.95
Saint Honore Eclair (Vanilla & Praline)
$8.95
Bread Pudding
$7.00
French Pastries, Tarts, Eclairs
Large Cookies & Sweets
Black & White Cookie
$5.95
Rainbow Sprinkle Cookie
$5.65
Chocolate Sprinkle Cookie
$5.65
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$5.65
Linzer Tart Cookie
$6.20
M&M Cookie
$5.65
Sugar Cookie
$5.65
Plain Chinese Cookie
$5.60
Chocolate Marble Chinese Cookie
$5.60
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
$5.65
Christmas Cookie Tin (28)
$56.15
1.5 Pound Assorted Butter Cookie Tray
$52.40
2 Pound Assorted Butter Cookie Tray
$67.80
3 Pound Cookie Tray
$96.85
5 Pound Cookie Tray
$148.15
7 Piece Assorted Macaroon Box
$27.45
Cookies by the Pound
Coffee / Espresso/ Tea / Hot Coco
Small Hot Chocolate
$4.40
Large Hot Chocolate
$6.90
Small Cold Brew
$6.20
Large Cold Brew
$6.20
Small Iced Americano
$5.65
Large Iced Americano
$6.20
Small Oat Milk Draft Latte
$7.20
Large Oat Milk Draft Latte
$8.15
Small Brown Sugar Oat Milk Draft Latte
$8.45
Large Brown Sugar Oat Milk Draft Latte
$9.35
Small Hot Coffee
$3.45
Large Hot Coffee
$4.95
Small Cappuccino
$4.95
Large Cappuccino
$5.65
Single Espresso
$4.05
Double Espresso
$5.05
Small Iced Macchiato
$5.65
Large Iced Macchiato
$6.20
Small Hot Macchiato
$4.40
Large Hot Macchiato
$5.65
Small Hot Latte
$5.35
Large Hot Latte
$5.95
Small Herbal Tea
$3.45
Large Herbal Tea
$4.05
Small Iced Herbal Tea
$4.70
Large Iced Herbal Tea
$5.35
Number 1 Candle
$2.95
Number 2 Candle
$2.95
Number 3 Candle
$2.95
Number 4 Candle
$2.95
Number 5 Candle
$2.95
Number 6 Candle
$2.95
Number 7 Candle
$2.95
Number 8 Candle
$2.95
Number 9 Candle
$2.95
Number 0 Candle
$2.95
10 Packaged Gold Spiral Candles
$3.00
16 Packaged White, Light Pink, Hot Pink, Gold Candles
$3.00
16 Packaged White, Light Blue, Dark Blue, Gold Candles
$3.00
Multi-Color Balloon Candles
$3.00
Gold "Happy Birthday" Letter Candles
$3.00
Candles
Custom Order (Cake, Bread, Cupcakes, Cookies, ETC...)
CUSTOM PICK-UP ORDER ONLY
$10.00